The Fun is Baked In

Peter Piper Pizza

The Challenge:

As a legacy family brand, Peter Piper Pizza faced a constant balancing act: staying culturally relevant in fast-moving social feeds while preserving the nostalgia and emotional connection generations grew up with. Commit was tasked with keeping the brand top of mind, driving meaningful engagement and evolving communications to ensure they could prevail in a modern social culture.

 

Social Media:

A Peter Piper Pizza ad with a pizza covered in ranch. Ranch Lovers Dream
someone holding an open pizza box
A cartoon of a kid holding a slice of pizza
Spotify Wrapped cover for 2025
A collage of Peter Piper Pizza menu items
a women eating a slice of pizza
A mock up of a record for "In Our Arcade Era"
Chella poster for Peter Piper Pizza

Commit’s Strategy:

Engaging our proprietary Challenger Brand Marketing® approach, Commit’s strategy embraced trend-driven, culturally relevant storytelling without forcing the brand into moments that didn’t feel authentic. From tapping into viral moments as they happened and leveraging nostalgia to spark emotional connection to using humor that was approachable, timely and shareable, Commit captured and produced content that felt native to each platform rather than overly polished or promotional. Prioritizing relevance over volume, this approach ensured Peter Piper Pizza showed up where conversations were already happening, thereby elevating their social standing across platforms and audiences.

 

Photography:

A mother and her two kids sitting at a table at Peter Piper Pizza
A family playing arcade games at a Peter Piper Pizza
A mother and a daughter playing ski ball at Peter Piper Pizza
A pepperoni pizza on a table decorated for a Birthday party

Measurable Results:

Significant year-over-year growth was achieved across platforms, driven by a content strategy designed to scale reach while deepening engagement. On Facebook, performance surged 150% YoY with 98.4M impressions, paired with a 25% increase in engagement and a 90% spike in video views, reinforcing the role of video-led creative in expanding visibility and interaction. And on Instagram, engagement growth outpaced reach, signaling stronger content resonance. Commit’s strategy and implementation generated 86% more impressions alongside a 155% boost in engagement, proving audiences were not just seeing the content, but actively engaging with it.

 

Email:

Double Up email for Peter Piper Pizza
$10 bonus Card email for Peter Piper Pizza
Gather. Dine. Play. Celebrate email for Peter Piper Pizza

Are You a Challenger Brand?

Want to take on the industry giants and win? We can help.

 

Check Out Some More Cool Stuff

More Case Studies

SanTan Brewing Company

SanTan Brewing Company

View Case Study
Hickman’s Eggs

Hickman’s Eggs

View Case Study